Time and materials vs fixed price: which way should you charge for a job?

Fixed price or time and materials? Compare both on the same job with real numbers, see where each goes wrong and when a hybrid works best.

A hand pulling a tape measure across weathered deck boards, with a hammer lying beside them.

The short answer

A fixed price charges one agreed total whatever the job takes, so you carry the risk of surprises. Time and materials bills the actual hours and materials, so the client carries it. Fixed price suits jobs you can see and measure. Time and materials suits repairs and jobs with unknowns. A hybrid, such as an hourly rate with a not-to-exceed cap, often fits best.

A client wants a quote for rebuilding the stairs on their back deck. You can see most of it, but not what is under the old boards. If you quote one price, you guess. If you bill by the hour, the client guesses. Which of you should carry the risk is the whole question.

What are time and materials and fixed price?

  • Fixed price: you agree one total before the work and charge it, whatever the job takes.
  • Time and materials: you charge the hours worked at an agreed rate, plus the materials actually used.

In the first, you carry the risk of a job that runs long. In the second, the client does. Everything else follows from that.

What does the same job cost both ways?

You expect the deck stair repair to take 24 hours. Your labour rate is $65 an hour and you expect $1,400 of materials. That is $1,560 of labour plus $1,400 of materials, or $2,960.

Fixed price: you add a $340 allowance for surprises and quote $3,300. Time and materials: you quote $65 an hour plus materials at cost, with an estimate of about $2,960.

Then you take the old boards off and find rot in the stringers. The job runs 34 hours and the materials come to $1,650.

The deck repair priced both ways
DetailFixed priceTime and materials
What the client pays$3,300$3,860
Your labour (34 hours)$2,210 at $65$2,210 at $65
Materials$1,650$1,650
What is left for your labour$1,650, or $48.53 an hour$2,210, or $65 an hour
Who carried the surpriseYouThe client

On time and materials, 34 hours at $65 is $2,210, plus $1,650 of materials, for $3,860. On fixed price, the client still pays $3,300 and you earn $1,650 for 34 hours of work, which is $48.53 an hour instead of the $65 you planned.

Had the job gone well and taken 20 hours, the picture flips. Fixed price would have paid you well for fast work and time and materials would have paid less. Neither method is fair on its own. It depends on what you can see before you start.

Where does each pricing method go wrong?

  • Fixed price goes wrong when you cannot see the scope and you guess low to win the job, then do the extra work for nothing.
  • Time and materials goes wrong when the client has no idea of the final bill and is shocked by the invoice.
  • Both go wrong when the scope is vague. Write down what is included and what is not.

Is there a middle path between the two?

You do not have to pick one pure method. Two hybrids are common:

  • Time and materials with a not-to-exceed cap. You bill actual time and materials but agree not to pass a stated total, such as $4,000, without the client's approval. The client has a ceiling and you are paid for the work.
  • Fixed price with a clear exclusion. You fix the price for the work you can see and write that hidden damage, such as rot found when the boards come off, is priced separately once it is found.

For the deck, either would have protected you. The cap covers a $3,860 bill. The exclusion lets you price the rot as a change order before you fix it.

How does each method look on the invoice?

A fixed-price invoice shows the agreed total, any deposit already paid and the balance. Change orders go on their own lines. A time-and-materials invoice shows hours with the date and the task, your rate, and each material at cost or with your markup. Clients accept a bigger bill much more easily when they can see the hours and receipts.

How do you choose between time and materials and fixed price?

  1. Can you see and measure all of the work? Choose fixed price.
  2. Is it a repair, or will you open something up to find out? Choose time and materials, or fixed price with an exclusion.
  3. Does the client need a firm number to get approval? Choose fixed price or a not-to-exceed cap.
  4. Is it a long job with a lot of change? Choose time and materials, billed in stages.

How do you check your numbers before you quote?

Before you quote either way, work out the price that gives you the profit you want. Our free service price calculator takes your hours, hourly rate, materials and a profit markup and shows the price to charge. Then send the quote or the invoice from your phone before you leave the site.

Common questions

What is the difference between time and materials and fixed price?

With fixed price you agree one total before the work and charge that amount however long the job takes. With time and materials you charge for the hours worked at an agreed rate plus the materials actually used. Fixed price puts the risk on you. Time and materials puts it on the client.

Which is better for a contractor?

Neither is better in every case. Fixed price works when you can see the whole job and measure it. Time and materials works for repairs, renovations in old buildings and anything where you cannot know the scope until you open it up.

How do I price a fixed-price job safely?

Estimate the hours and materials honestly, add an allowance for surprises, then check the price still leaves you the profit you want. Write down what is included and what is not, and agree that anything outside it is a change order.

What is a not-to-exceed price?

It is a time and materials job with a cap. You bill actual hours and materials but agree you will not go above a stated total without the client's approval. It gives the client a ceiling and you the freedom to bill what the job really takes.